Guidelines' Guidelines. (Is there an echo in here?) by Ed Churnside
Every freelance, magazine writer reads a lot of submission
guidelines. Because of a current project, I see more than most, about
50 per week. While the national glossies have it down, smaller
publications are often missing vital information and ezines
(electronic or internet magazines) are usually terrible.
While guidelines containing spelling, grammatical and
punctuation errors are amusing, incomplete guidelines are a more
serious problem. They generate a lot of inquiries and inappropriate
submissions wasting the editor's valuable time. Poor guidelines often
force me to submit to a better documented publication. (I will
usually Email questions for a paying market but stamps cost money and
I don't waste time on freebies.)
Print magazines that have not already done so, should get their
guidelines on the internet as soon as possible. No credible
publication can afford not to have some on-line presence. The whole
SASE business is an interesting tribute to a bygone era that only
wastes time and money. On the web, writers will use the current
guidelines in preference to ones they received five years ago. The
internet also provides an easy access to an international community
of writers.
Ezines almost universally have on-line guidelines but they need
to get them up to par: just because an ezine does not pay, does not
excuse sloppiness. If the editor cannot edit her own guidelines for
accuracy and completeness, why should I trust her with my work?
The following two sections provide detailed help in writing and
setting up guidelines. The Tips provide a quick list of do's and
don'ts when putting guidelines on a web page: almost every guideline
I have seen could use this advice. The Outline provides a structure
and a fairly complete list of the information needed in a good
guideline. I hope this helps editors and writers alike establish
better communications that will lead to better submissions.
Tips for on-line-guidelines.
- Don't get fancy: there is no need for a guideline page to be
pretty. The less graphics and formatting used the better. Plain text
is easier for the writer to download and save.
- Don't put vital information only in graphics. While it may look
nice it won't show up in search engines, bookmarks or saved
copies.
- Don't put vital information only in the frame either for the
same three reasons.
- Put the magazines full name and "Magazine Submission Guidelines"
in the Title. This information will show up in bookmarks and search
engines. This will make it easier for writers to find them.
- Remember a search engine will show the Title and a few lines so
make the start is an advertisement for the magazine.
- Date the title and the heading.
- Make sure that staff names, Email addresses, etc. are on the
guideline page even if this information is elsewhere. Don't make
writers cut-and-paste when they save a copy.
- Make sure the guideline page has a link back to the top page.
Don't rely on the browser's back-button. Writers entering from a
bookmark or search, need the link.
- Register with services like the Guide to on-line Guidelines (http://www.snafu.de/~gadfly)
and Inkspot (http://www.inkspot.com) who
maintain guideline databases.
- Contact the major search engines to make sure the main page and
the guideline page are cataloged.
- Writers should always save a copy of guidelines. A hard copy can
be referenced when not on-line and gives some basis for argument if
the rules change during submission.
Here is an example of how a fictional magazine's guidelines might
start. If I found this one in a search, I guarantee I would go
there.
<HTML>
<TITLE>
Widget's World Submission Guidelines (Dec 25, 1998)
</TITLE>
<BODY>
<B><FONT SIZE="1">Widget's World Submission Guidelines. Dec 25, 1998.
</FONT></B><BR><BR>
Widget's World is a monthly ezine which pays up to $30 for articles,
stories and poems about the love and use of widgets. We enjoy working
with new authors and every submission receives a personal
review....
An Outline of Submission Guidelines.
- Overview. A 3-4 line piece of self advertising which is useful
in on-line guidelines. See notes and example above.
- Name. It is amazing how often this is omitted.
- Topic. What is the magazine about?
- General Comments. What are you looking for in a general sense?
Save specifics for the following sections.
- Don't say, "Send only your very best writing." For Atlantic
Monthly it is an appropriate comment but a magazine that pays $10 for
5000 words should expect to be near the bottom of the food chain. http://www2.theatlantic.com
- Don't say, "Read the last five issues for style," unless they
are archived on the internet or commonly available in libraries. One
local magazine wanted $5 plus $2 postage per back issue. It would
have cost me $35 to research a $2 poem -- no thank you.
- Readership. Who do you think reads your magazine?
- How do you publish: print, ezine, newsletter etc.? Don't assume
I know. I may find your information out of context.
- What is the frequency: monthly, quarterly etc.? This is
especially important for ezines.
- Rights: what are you buying? I believe that it is the clear
definition of the rights wanted that distinguishes a true ezine from
a glorified home page. Writers should NOT submit material without
knowing rights even to a non-paying market.
- For Print it's usually FNASR (First North American Serial
Rights) or FSR (First Serial Rights).
- For ezines try FER (First Electronic Rights), FR (First Rights),
One Time Rights -- copyright stays with author, Limited Archive
Rights, etc.
- Do NOT ask for ALL rights unless you are paying big bucks. For
$4000 Omni Magazine can have all rights and the body part of their
choice. I have seen vanity ezines that expect them for free. http://www.omnimag.com/fiction/datlow/guidelines.html
- Writer's Market has a good section on rights. Available from http://www.BarnesandNoble.com
- Copyright. Tell me my work will be protected. You don't really
need to but tell me anyway -- I'm paranoid. See Brad Templeton's "10
Myths about Copyrights" for a lot of useful information about
internet rights. http://www.temple
tons.com/brad/copymyths.html
- Do you like new writers; work with a few; prefer experienced
writers; or use agents only?
- When do I get paid: on acceptance, on publication, royalties or
non-paying? If it is royalties, then explain the basis. If non-
paying, then say so explicitly. I file non-paying magazines
separately from semi-pro; please don't make me wade through the
guidelines looking for your terms.
- Rate: how much do you pay?
- Use flat rate or per word (per line for poetry).
- If you use a weird unit like per page or per column inch, then
give an approximate per word equivalent.
- Make sure currency is clear if posting on internet: Australia,
Canada, New Zealand and the USA are all English speaking (more-or-
less) and use dollars.
- If you have different rates for different material, put the rate
information in the relevant section.
- Personal Review. A personal review is a big plus. If you give
one for every submission, make sure you say so loudly.
- Simultaneous Submissions: do you allow them?
- Reprints: what do you allow and at what rate? Do you want a
photocopy? What do you want if it was published on web?
- Email Submissions: Do you allow them and what about
queries?
- The less you pay, the more you should consider allowing Email
submissions. An 5000 word story costs about $2 to mail. For less than
$30 it is not worth the risk.
- Consider allowing short, low paying items like fillers and
poetry to be emailed.
- Consider allowing queries to be emailed.
- Never let Email submissions come to your normal address. Set up
a separate account. You can get a free Email account from Yahoo if
you need one. http://www.yahoo.com
- What do you want in the Email title: department name, column
name etc.? Email programs like Eudora can provide automatic folders.
http://www.eudora.com/
- Byline. Tell me if you do not give a byline.
- Lead Time. What's the average time to publication?
- Seasonal Lead Time. What's the lead time for seasonal
items?
- Review Time. How long before I start bugging you?
- Kill Fee. How much do I get if you change your mind?
- Freelance Percentage. How much is written by freelancers?
- Circulation. How many do you distribute and where?
- This is important when planning reprints.
- For an ezine say how many hits per issue.
- Cover Letter: do you want one? What should it say?
- Author's bio. Do you want one? How big? Do you want a
photograph?
- Published clips. Do you want them?
Non-Fiction.
- Minimum and maximum number of words
- Rate if different to overview.
- Number of articles bought per issue
- Topics allowed in addition to main topic
- Type of article: how-to, humor, inspirational, etc.
- What not to send.
- Do you give assignments?
- Do you pay expenses?
- Are queries required?
Fiction.
- Minimum and maximum number of words
- Rate if different to overview.
- Number of stories bought per issue.
- opics allowed in addition to main topic.
- Genre: fantasy, romance, mystery, science fiction, etc.
- What not to send.
- Are queries required?
Poetry.
- Minimum and maximum number of lines
- Rate if different to overview (Poetry is usually
different.)
- Number of poems bought per issue
- Topics allowed in addition to main topic
- Format of poems: Free verse, light verse, haiku, etc.
- What not to send.
- How many poems can I submit in a batch?
Columns. For each column you should state:
- Name of column.
- Minimum and maximum number of words
- Rate if different to overview.
- Number of items per issue
- Description of column
Filler.
- Minimum and maximum number of words
- Rate if different to overview.
- Number of fillers bought per issue.
- Topics allowed in addition to main topic.
- Type of article: anecdote, short humor, etc.
Photographs or Artwork.
- Description. What do you want? What don't you want?
- Color. BW or Color?
- Format. Transparencies, prints or computer graphics?
- Format for Email or floppy: BMP, JPG or GIF, etc.?
- Size: 3.5x5", 8x10", 800x600 pixels, etc.?
- Type: 35 mm, Digital, 16 color bitmap, etc.?
- Model releases required?
- Captions required?
- Rate?
- Rights. Usually One Time Rights for photographs.
- Send graphics only with articles?
- How many items allowed per submission?
- Always include a reminder not to send originals.
Contact Information
- Staff. List the publisher, managing editor, submissions
editor and section editors if appropriate.
- Address. Ezines should give a postal address but usually
don't. If the page disappears while owing you money, how are you
supposed to contact them?
- Phone.
- Fax.
- Email address. You may mention Email submissions here.
- URL.
Printed Manuscript Format.
- Many people think that standard format is 12 pt courier double
spaced (poetry single spaced), single sided and underline for
italics. Legal name, address, phone number and Email address go at
top left of first page. Word count (line count for poetry), rights
offered, copyright and "disposable" go at top right of first page.
Title, "by" and pen name take up 3 lines centered 1/3 of the way down
the first page. Name, abbreviated title and page count go at top of
each page after first.
- Don't change this format without a good reason. If you do,
spell it out explicitly.
- If you expect a lot of bibliographic or reference material you
may want to indicate the style you prefer. You may refer to books
like The Chicago Manual of Style (available from http://www.amazon.com) or style
websites like: http:
//succeed.che.ufl.edu/help/style/style_abstract.html http://www.lehi
gh.edu/~inhelp/footnote/apa.html
Email Format.
- How do I send you my document? You should accept major word
processing files as attachments: it's more convenient for everyone.
The other two common methods -- ASCII attachments and pasting into
the Email -- both lose formatting information. If you must use these
methods, publish standards for how to indicate bold, italic,
etc.
- What should I put in the heading? (See prior note on
automating your Email.)
- If you want HTML coding embedded in documents then you should
provide an example or refer to style guides like: http://www.ability.org/hstyl
e.html http://www.fairfield.edu/
ourstyle.htm
Brought to you by: World Wide Information Outlet - http://www.certificate.net/wwio/, your source of FREE Content online.

Ed Churnside is a freelance writer, programmer and web designer. While he has written articles on subjects as diverse as Internet etiquette, astronomy, woodworking and bunnies, Ed, a self-confessed computer wizard, is probably best unknown for his programming. "About 50% of Americans have used programs I designed," he says enigmatically and grins. Winner of the prestigious Atari Consumer Products Award, Ed now spends his time writing articles and short fiction, programming shareware and freeware, and maintaining several web sites. He can be reached at Wulf@DragonQuest.com
or via his website at http://www.DragonQuest.com
ANNOUCING OUR SISTER SITE: ArticlesOn.com - Free Content, Free Articles, Free Article Database & Free Article Submission. Free article search for free content for your website. Find free articles for reprint and writers get free article submission. Free web content and free articles online.
Check out our Topics
|
|
You Hate to Follow Up
Mind if we do it for you? AWeber's unlimited autoresponder follow up increases
sales, lowers costs, builds lasting customer relationships, and
increases your profits!
Find out how with Unlimited Autoresponders.
|
|
|
|
© Copyright 1997-2006. All rights reserved. Contact: World Wide Information Outlet
|